If you're evaluating practice management software in 2026, SimplePractice is almost certainly on your list. With 250,000+ practitioners and years of product investment, it's a legitimate option — not a trap. But its pricing structure has changed substantially since its private equity acquisition, and the gap between the advertised price and what solo and small-group practices actually pay is wider than most therapists realize before they sign up.
This comparison covers both platforms without pulling punches. SimplePractice does some things well. MindDesk does some things differently. The question isn't which is objectively better — it's which one makes sense for the way your practice actually operates.
The Pricing Structure, Side by Side
SimplePractice offers three tiers. The entry-level Starter plan ($29/mo) has no telehealth — making it unusable for most practicing therapists. The Essential plan ($69/mo) adds telehealth and insurance billing. MindDesk is $49/mo for solo practitioners and $99/mo for group practices — telehealth, intake automation, scheduling, billing, and client communications included at every tier, no add-ons required.
The real comparison: SimplePractice Starter is $29/mo — but has no telehealth. To get telehealth, you move to Essential at $69/mo. MindDesk Solo is $49/mo and includes telehealth out of the box. You get telehealth for $20/less per month — plus no per-claim fees, no per-SMS charges, and AI intake automation included.
| Plan | SimplePractice | MindDesk |
|---|---|---|
| Solo practitioner | $29/mo (Starter, no telehealth) or $69/mo (Essential, telehealth included) | $49/mo — all features included |
| Group practice | $99/mo (Plus) + $59/mo per additional clinician | $99/mo — multiple therapists, flat fee |
| Telehealth included | ✗ Not on $29 Starter · ✓ $69+ Essential | ✓ Every plan, no upgrade needed |
| Insurance claim filing | Essential ($69/mo) and above only | ✓ Included |
| Per-claim fee | $0.25/claim (after free trial) | ✓ No per-claim fees |
| SMS reminders | ~$0.04/text (add-on) | ✓ Included |
| Credit card processing | 3.15% + $0.30/transaction | Standard market rates |
| AI intake automation | ✗ Manual intake forms only | ✓ AI-automated intake |
| HIPAA BAA | ✓ All plans | ✓ All plans |
Savings math for a solo therapist: MindDesk Solo ($49/mo) vs SimplePractice Essential ($69/mo) = $20/mo saved on base subscription. Add back $25–75/mo in per-claim fees and $12–15/mo in SMS charges that are included in MindDesk, and the real difference is $57–$110/month — or up to $1,320/year.
See MindDesk pricing in action
$49/mo solo. $99/mo group. Every feature included. We'll show you the full workflow in 30 minutes.
Request a Demo →No commitment. Compare against your current platform cost.
What SimplePractice Actually Costs a Solo Therapist
The number therapists most often quote when describing SimplePractice is $69/month — that's the Essential plan, which is the lowest tier that includes both telehealth and insurance billing. Here's what that actually costs a solo therapist seeing 25 clients per week, with a typical insurance billing volume:
Base plan (Essential)
$69/moThis is the minimum viable plan for a practicing therapist who offers telehealth and bills any insurance. The $49/mo Starter plan does not include insurance claim filing, making it effectively unusable for most insurance-accepting practices.
Per-claim fees: $0.25 per claim submitted
+$25–75/mo typicalA practice submitting 100–300 insurance claims per month — a reasonable volume for a solo clinician with a mixed caseload — adds $25–75/month in claim fees. At 300 claims, that's an additional $900/year on top of the subscription. The first 35 claims are included on the Plus plan; on Essential, every claim carries the fee.
SMS appointment reminders: ~$0.04/text
+$10–40/mo typicalSMS reminders are not included in the subscription — they're billed per message sent. A practice sending three reminders per patient (72hr, 24hr, day-of) across 25 clients per week generates approximately 75 texts/week, or 300+ texts/month. That adds $12–15/month at minimum before any rescheduling confirmations.
Credit card processing: 3.15% + $0.30 per transaction
+$30–90/mo typicalSimplePractice's processing rate of 3.15% + $0.30 is above standard Stripe rates (2.9% + $0.30). For a practice collecting $3,000–$8,000/month in client payments, this markup adds $7.50–$20/month over market rate — not a huge number, but worth knowing it's there.
Total realistic cost for a solo therapist on Essential: $69 base + $25–75 in claims + $12–15 in SMS + processing fees = $106–$159/month before client payment processing volume. Billed annually, that's $1,272–$1,908 per year in platform costs alone.
The Features That Actually Differ
Intake Automation
The Core Difference
SimplePractice handles intake forms — it can send them to patients, collect responses, and attach them to client records. What it doesn't do is automate the intake workflow end-to-end. Your front office still triggers the forms, follows up on incomplete submissions, and manually reviews what comes in.
MindDesk's Approach
MindDesk was built around AI intake automation. Forms go out automatically on booking confirmation. Incomplete submissions trigger follow-ups without staff involvement. Responses are parsed and flagged for clinical review, not raw form dumps. If reducing front-office time on intake is a priority — rather than just digitizing a paper form — this is a meaningful difference. See 5 Signs Your Therapy Practice Needs Better Intake Automation for the full picture on what automated intake actually changes.
Scheduling and Reminders
SimplePractice's Approach
SimplePractice offers solid scheduling. Online booking works. Calendar sync is functional. Reminders exist — with per-SMS costs. For practices that want a reliable, established scheduling tool and are comfortable with the add-on cost structure, it does the job.
MindDesk's Approach
MindDesk includes a three-touchpoint SMS reminder cadence (72hr, 24hr, day-of) in the base plan, without per-message fees. Two-way confirmation is built in — patients confirm or reschedule via SMS reply, and the system updates the calendar automatically. If your no-show rate is a problem, the SMS cadence matters more than the scheduling UI. See our article on reducing no-shows in your therapy practice for data on what actually moves the needle.
Documentation and EHR Depth
SimplePractice's Advantage
SimplePractice has been building clinical documentation tools for years. Its template library, progress note workflow, and treatment plan features are mature. If you need deep EHR functionality — complex treatment planning, detailed outcome tracking, nuanced session note templates — SimplePractice's documentation layer is more developed than MindDesk's current offering.
MindDesk's Focus
MindDesk's documentation is designed for the operational workflow: intake to session to billing, without gaps or manual transfer steps. The trade-off is that it doesn't yet have SimplePractice's depth on the clinical note side. If your primary need is practice operations — intake, scheduling, billing, follow-ups — MindDesk is purpose-built for that. If you need a full clinical EHR with extensive documentation templates, SimplePractice's depth is a real consideration.
Group Practice Scaling
The Add-On Math
SimplePractice's Plus plan ($99/mo) supports multiple clinicians at $59/month each. A 3-clinician practice on Plus costs $99 + (2 × $59) = $217/month before claim fees, SMS costs, and processing. A 5-clinician practice is $99 + (4 × $59) = $335/month base — before variable fees that scale with volume.
MindDesk's Approach
MindDesk's Group Practice plan is $99/mo flat — unlimited clinicians, no per-seat add-ons. A 3-clinician practice on MindDesk pays $99/mo. A 5-clinician practice pays $99/mo. The cost structure doesn't compound with headcount. For a 3-clinician practice, that's $217/mo (SimplePractice Plus) vs $99/mo (MindDesk Group) — a difference of $118/mo before any per-claim or SMS costs. If you're currently solo but planning to grow, this difference becomes significant faster than most therapists expect when they're pricing out their first tool.
HIPAA Compliance: Both Check the Box
Both platforms include a Business Associate Agreement (BAA) on all plans. Both encrypt data at rest and in transit. Both are used by tens of thousands of practicing clinicians without documented compliance failures. HIPAA compliance should be on your checklist, but it's not a differentiator between these two platforms.
If HIPAA compliance is a concern for your specific tech stack, see our HIPAA compliance checklist for therapy practice technology — it covers the full surface area beyond just the EHR.
When SimplePractice Is the Right Choice
SimplePractice makes sense if: you need deep clinical documentation with extensive note templates, you're already on the platform and the migration cost outweighs the savings, your insurance billing volume is low enough that per-claim fees don't compound significantly, or you need the depth of an established EHR more than operational automation. With 250,000+ practitioners and years of product investment, it's not going away. Its support infrastructure, template library, and Monarch directory integration are real advantages.
When MindDesk Is the Right Choice
MindDesk makes sense if: you're evaluating platforms before committing, your front-office admin load is a primary pain point, you want intake-to-billing automation without assembling pieces from multiple tools, or you're a group practice where per-seat pricing compounds quickly. At $49/mo for solo practitioners and $99/mo for group practices — with telehealth, intake automation, scheduling, and SMS reminders all included — the math is straightforward.
If you're searching for a SimplePractice alternative because the pricing has escalated past your threshold — or because you're paying for Essential ($69/mo) just to get telehealth that should be standard — MindDesk is built for that exact situation. The fastest way to evaluate is to see it running against your actual workflow. For a broader look at how all major platforms stack up, see our 2026 buyer's guide to the best therapy practice management software.
See MindDesk configured for your practice
$49/mo solo · $99/mo group. 30 minutes. We'll show you the full intake-to-billing workflow including what the patient experience looks like and what your front office stops doing manually.
Request a Demo →No commitment. Just the real product against your real questions.